Legal experts say members of a Discord group linked to Charlie Kirk’s accused killer, Tyler Robinson, are unlikely to face charges unless there is evidence of direct involvement in the crime. Hours before his arrest, Robinson allegedly confessed in the chat, saying, “Hey guys, I have bad news for you all… It was me at UVU yesterday… I’m sorry for all of this.” The FBI is now reviewing messages from this group as part of its investigation.

FBI Director Kash Patel explained that while many assume it’s easy to identify all participants in online chats, the reality is more complex. Investigators are obtaining search warrants and interviewing numerous individuals connected to the Discord group to gather legally admissible evidence. Patel said the FBI is also working closely with Robinson’s family and community to understand his beliefs and ideology.

Senator Josh Hawley questioned Patel about potential accomplices or influences, and Patel confirmed that the FBI is thoroughly investigating everyone involved in the group, which reportedly includes more than 20 members.

Legal scholars clarify that simply witnessing or ignoring a confession online does not constitute a crime. Eugene Volokh, UCLA Law Professor Emeritus, stated that hearing or seeing someone admit a crime and doing nothing is generally not illegal. Former federal prosecutor Andy McCarthy added that prosecution would only apply if individuals actively participated in or agreed to the crime plan.

Both experts emphasized that mere silence or passive online presence is insufficient for criminal charges, noting that more concrete evidence of involvement is necessary for prosecution.